There’s a new hidden bar in town! We recently visited The Stache, located inside Renny's, and were blown away by the drinks, the space, and the overall speakeasy experience!
Updated November 2023
THE STACHE
The restaurant is named after Renny, owner Mark Maguire’s father, and the speakeasy is named for his epic mustache, which has been well-known for the past 60+ years! The secret bar just opened this week, and is the perfect counterpart to Renny’s.
The intimate, dimly-lit space seats only about 30 people, which makes for the perfect cozy vibes! You’ll find eclectic decor like neon signs, exposed brick, kitstchy art, and of course, hidden mustaches throughout.
THE MENU
Enjoy dishes from the restaurant menu focused on seafood and an exclusive cocktail menu. The drinks are mostly gin, vodka, and whiskey-based, along with some agave spirits, wine, and champagne too! The cocktail menu is ever-evolving, with a holiday menu coming soon!
The space seriously feels like you’re at a true NYC speakeasy, so soak up the retro vibes at the bar while you sip cocktails, or cozy up on a velvet couch with some friends and apps!
WHAT WE ORDERED
🌸 A Gap in the Clouds
🍋 Cain & Abel
🥃 Old Fashioned
🍸 Mezcal Last Word (we loved their unique take on this!)
🍟 Truffle Fries
🍣 Ahi Tuna Nachos
HOW TO GET IN
This hotspot is only open to the public on Wednesdays and Thursdays, and reservations are required! You can also be invited in if you’re lucky on other nights! To get in, you’ll have to find the entrance which is hidden inside the restaurant, then use a few clues to guess the entry password. If you get it correct, a secret door will open and you’re in!
Hint: the password changes nightly and is based on different famous people with notable mustaches!
